Gary’s 5-star review:
Great diner food and best portions in town! I've always complained about lousy diners in New York City, especially in Queens. I grew up around Georgia Diner, Sage Diner/Pops Diner/Fabulous Nevada Diner, Forest Hills Diner, T-Bone Diner, Tower Diner, Jackson Hole, nearly every diner you could possibly think of in our area, they all stunk!! The quality and portions for the price they charged were always terrible! Service in all of those diners were always dreadful. My friend suggested Good Eats diner and kept telling me how good it was. I was skeptical at first but I decided to give it a try.
Good Eats is located on Grand Ave in Maspeth. It's a few blocks away from my old intermediate school (I.S.73). I could not recall this place being opened during my years in junior high which was over 15 years ago. I brought my wife and son for breakfast and we had one heck of a meal. We ordered a Good Eats waffle special, 1 Belgian waffle with a side of eggs, ham, bacon, and toast, eggs Benedict w/ a side of avocados, and a western omelette. Each of our meals included a juice.
The waffle was pretty fluffy on the inside. I wished the outer part, especially the edges of the waffle would be but more crispier. It was almost a pancake like texture. The eggs, bacon were fine, the ham however was a bit cheap tasting. It be nicer if it was a slice of Virginia ham or a thicker cut of ham to go with the eggs.
Eggs Benedict is the standout meal of our breakfast. The hollandaise sauce was perfect, served with a side of hash browns, it was a dynamite meal. Last but not least was the Western omelette. This omelette was ginormous! It's really thick and also served with a side of hash browns. It was really good, my son certainly enjoyed it. Most omelettes served in diners are flat with minimal amount of ingredients. This western omelette was quite loaded and filling.
Verdict - Great diner, perhaps the best diner in Queens. The prices were fair and reasonable, pretty much similar prices to all of the other diners I mentioned. What makes Good Eats stand out from the rest is their quality and portions. You get so much more for your money here. I was very pleased with my meal, the one tiny downer is that I wish they brought out our food the second it was ready instead of waiting for all it to be ready together. I felt some foods cooled off before it reached our table. Other that, this is quite a gem for this neighborhood.
On a side note, the take out menu is vastly different from the dine-in menu. The takeout menu stretches, page after page, item after item in small text. The dine-in menu was like two huge pages with pictures and text. Maybe they have separate menus for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. I'll find out and keep y'all posted.